Background

‘’The Good Girl’’ Book Review

Article arrow_drop_down

A Disappointing Thriller Riddled with Predictability and Problematic Undertones

Genre: Mystery, Thriller

“The Good Girl” is arguably one of the most disappointing books I’ve encountered, and there’s a lot to dissect here. While some readers have rated it highly, giving it four stars, my experience was drastically different. I do understand why some might enjoy it, as there are moments that aren’t entirely dreadful, but the majority of issues stem from the book’s final chapter.

To be clear: this story offers no satisfying or redeeming qualities. The plot summary essentially reveals the entire narrative. Mia meets a stranger at a bar who then kidnaps her. That’s the crux of the book. The narrative is divided into two timelines: Mia’s initial encounter and abduction by Colin, and her life after being rescued and returning home. From the outset, we know the outcome—Mia survives and goes home—erasing any potential suspense. The supposed mystery around her kidnapping, filled with dodgy characters and questionable backgrounds, fails to distract from the predictability. I anticipated the twist early on.

The kidnapping chapters are narrated in third-person omniscient, focusing on Colin, the kidnapper. Since Mia and Colin are strangers, it’s hard to sympathize with Mia’s plight initially. Colin’s indifference towards her makes it challenging for the reader to care as well. Even as their relationship evolves, Mia remains a one-dimensional character, since we learn about her alongside Colin. Her development of Stockholm Syndrome is unsettling and creepy, likely intentional, but the perspective through Colin’s eyes amplifies the discomfort. To the author’s credit, Colin is a well-crafted character, if not a deep one. He sees himself as a victim, providing his side of the story, yet remains the clear villain. The resemblance to Joe from “You” is unmistakable.

As mentioned, the plot’s revelation early on makes for an insufferably slow story. I wasn’t invested in Colin and Mia’s survival in the woods because their fate was already known. The detective’s search for them lacked tension for the same reason. The final chapter’s “twist” was unsurprising, filled with clichés and mystery tropes, and introduced additional plot holes ignored for dramatic effect.

The most significant issues, however, emerge in the final chapter. Early in the story, subtle but troubling lines hint at the author’s problematic views. Descriptions of an “ethnic” area being safer because it’s “nearly half-white” and derogatory comments about predominantly African American neighborhoods were concerning but initially shrugged off.

The author’s biases become glaring in the last chapter. Mia describes a bar as a “hole in the wall,” covered in graffiti, noting she was “the only one who was white.” The repeated emphasis on the racial makeup of the bar’s patrons is troubling. The introduction of the only Black character, a Somali villain depicted in a highly offensive manner, is particularly appalling. Describing him with comparisons to dangerous animals and using terms like “rubbery” skin and “anthracite eyes” is not only dehumanizing but also racist. The insistence on emphasizing his blackness to convey menace is deeply problematic.

Additionally, the book perpetuates the notion that women’s ultimate purpose is motherhood and includes a heavy-handed anti-abortion message. The subplot where the daughter is raped and the parents refuse abortion is handled in a morally prescriptive manner. Given my previous experiences with this author’s lackluster works, I have no qualms about declaring this the last book I will read from them.

About the author

Its Name Was Mormo - SUPERSCARED
trending_flat
‘Its Name Was Mormo’ Review: Fear-filled Hearts & Close Encounters

In Mark Bower’s staggering handmade visionary tale, his first movie has drawn the attention of nine international film distributors. A Haunting Tale Mark Bower's handmade visionary performance, "Its Name Was Mormo," is a haunting exploration of fear and the supernatural, capturing audiences with its raw and immersive storytelling which delves into the realm of psyche horror, evoking a sense of dread that lingers long after the camera battery dies. Plot and Atmosphere Set in a desolate, rural town, Its Name Was Mormo > follows the unsettling experiences of a family who encounter an evil entity known as Mormo. The film masterfully builds tension through its eerie landscapes, unsettling silence, and the palpable fear of its characters. Bower’s attention to detail in creating a chilling atmosphere is evident, as each scene is infused with an impending sense of doom. The narrative is […]

"The Legend of the Alley – Midnight’s Revenge" Horror Stories
trending_flat
“The Legend of the Alley – Midnight’s Revenge” Horror Stories

"The Legend of the Alley – Midnight’s Revenge" Horror Tales My name is Daniel, and to be honest, I never believed in ghosts or urban legends. However, what happened to me in that small Colombian town at midnight on a Wednesday changed my perspective radically. I will never forget that night, an experience that, to this day, makes me question what I thought I knew about reality. It was a rainy summer night in the tiny town where I was staying. The place, with its dark alleys and dilapidated houses, seemed straight out of a Gothic novel. The rain fell persistently, creating puddles on the ground and generating a constant sound of drops hitting the pavement. I was walking down a narrow alley, my head bowed under the hood of my coat, trying to avoid getting wet more than necessary. […]

"The Woman Behind the Curtain" Horror Stories
trending_flat
“The Woman Behind the Curtain” Horror Stories

"The Woman Behind the Curtain" Melisa, a 34-year-old woman who is elegant, serious, and preoccupied with her work, finds herself in the hospital. The sterile smell of antiseptic floats in the air as Melisa settles into the hospital bed, her eyes fixed on her phone screen. Work emails, updates, and endless tasks pile up in her digital world. Despite her kidney problems that brought her to the hospital, Melisa couldn’t stop immersing herself in work. It was the only thing that mattered, the only constant in her life that she could control. Melisa remained sitting in the hospital bed, occasionally writhing in pain but not paying much attention to it. The day passed uneventfully, with nurses coming in and out to administer medication and check her vital signs. Melisa noticed that the bed next to hers was separated by a […]

''Evil Dead: The Game'' - Two New ‘Halloween’ Video Games in Development
trending_flat
”Evil Dead: The Game” – Two New ‘Halloween’ Video Games in Development from ‘Evil Dead’

‘Evil Dead: The Game’ - Spooky Surprises Ahead: ‘Evil Dead: The Game’ Creators Crafting Two New Halloween Video Games Michael Myers is gearing up for a grand return to video games. IGN has unveiled exciting news that Boss Team Games, the studio renowned for Evil Dead: The Game, is working on not one but two new video games based on John Carpenter’s seminal slasher film, Halloween. The news is even more thrilling given that Carpenter himself is involved in at least one of these projects. While precise details about the games remain limited, it has been confirmed that both titles are being developed in close collaboration with the producers behind the Halloween franchise. Notably, one of the games will be powered by the cutting-edge Unreal Engine 5, promising a visually immersive and high-fidelity experience that will bring the terror of […]

‘'Hell Hole’' Review – A Gritty Creature Feature with Dark Humor
trending_flat
‘’Hell Hole’’ Review – A Gritty Creature Feature with Dark Humor

“Hell Hole” A Thrilling Fusion of Heavy Metal, Creature Feature Excitement, and Sharp-Witted Humor The Adams Family—comprising father John Adams, mother Tobey Poser, and their daughters—has become synonymous with a distinct punk rock, DIY filmmaking ethos. Their previous works, including The Deeper You Dig, Hellbender, and last year’s Where the Devil Roams, showcase their knack for blending creativity with a raw, hands-on approach. Their latest project, Hell Hole, continues this tradition with an inventive homage to classic creature features. It’s not just the gory monster effects that make this film stand out; it’s the Adams Family's ability to push creative boundaries, infusing the film with a playful, heavy metal vibe and a healthy dose of dark humor. ''Hell Hole'' begins in an unusual setting: Serbian territory in 1814. French soldiers, battling for Napoleon Bonaparte and led by a character played […]

''The Bench'' A Scottish Horror Film: The 17-Year Odyssey to Release
trending_flat
”The Bench” A Scottish Horror Film: The 17-Year Odyssey to Release

''The Bench'' - From Idea to Cult Classic: The 17-Year Saga of a Scottish Horror Film ''The Bench'' A Scottish horror film that has been in the making for nearly 17 years has finally emerged from its protracted journey. The Bench is a suspenseful slasher film revolving around a group of friends who, while staying at a remote cabin in Renfrewshire, encounter a series of terrifying events as they mysteriously disappear one by one. Although the concept seemed promising, the film’s production faced numerous hurdles, from Scotland's erratic weather to financial shortages that brought progress to a halt. Sean Wilkie, the film's writer and director, spoke candidly to BBC Scotland News about the emotional rollercoaster of seeing The Bench finally come to fruition. A Coatbridge native, Wilkie transitioned from short films to this full-length horror venture, drawing inspiration from horror […]

trending_flat
“Hold Your Breath” – New Horror Flick Landing on Hulu This October

“Hold Your Breath” A Spine-Chilling Dive into Fear and Suspense Searchlight Pictures has unveiled a series of haunting first-look images from their highly anticipated horror-thriller, Hold Your Breath. This spine-chilling film is set to make its exclusive debut on Hulu on October 3, 2024, just in time to inject a dose of terror into the Halloween festivities. Check our article "Its Name Was Mormo" The Influence of Found Footage in Horror > Starring the formidable Sarah Paulson, Hold Your Breath features an exceptional ensemble cast including Ebon Moss-Bachrach, Amiah Miller, and Annaleigh Ashford. With the directorial expertise of Karrie Crouse and William Joines, the film is poised to captivate and disturb audiences with its gripping narrative. The film’s setting is as ominous as its plot: 1930s Oklahoma, a landscape ravaged by relentless dust storms and an atmosphere thick with dread. […]

Related

Pet Sematary - Book Review
trending_flat
Pet Sematary – Book Review

Pet Sematary by Stephen King – A Fresh Look I found Pet Sematary to be an utterly captivating read this time around. Stephen King's exploration of grief, loss, and the boundaries of life and death pulled me in from the very first page. The way he weaves the supernatural elements with deep psychological tension kept me on edge throughout. Each twist and turn felt both inevitable and shocking, and the unsettling atmosphere he creates lingered long after I finished the book. It's a testament to King's mastery of horror that this story, which I thought I knew well, still managed to surprise and deeply affect me. The story begins with Louis Creed and his family relocating from Chicago to the small town of Ludlow, Maine. Louis is immediately apprehensive about the busy highway near their new home, especially with his […]

trending_flat
Book Review: Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Mexican Gothic: Unearthing the Shadows -A Dive into the Haunting Elegance of Silvia Moreno-Garcia "Mexican Gothic" by Silvia Moreno-Garcia, released in 2020, is a modern take on gothic horror that I was eager to read. This novel masterfully blends classic gothic elements with innovative perspectives on historical and contemporary themes. However, if body horror makes you uneasy, be prepared for some particularly unsettling scenes. The story centers on Noemi, a glamorous Mexican socialite, who ventures to a remote mansion to check on her cousin, Catalina. Noemi makes a deal with her father to continue funding her education in exchange for helping Catalina, who is found to be in a disturbingly deteriorated state. Despite her husband Virgil's dismissive claims that Catalina is merely depressed, Noemi suspects something far more sinister. As she delves deeper, the plot thickens and becomes increasingly eerie. […]

trending_flat
Book Review: Coraline by Neil Gaiman

Neil Gaiman’s ‘’Coraline’’, first published in 2002, is a dark fantasy novel that captivates readers of all ages. The story follows Coraline Jones, a young girl who, along with her parents, moves into a new apartment in a large, antiquated building divided into several units. Their neighbors include a pair of eccentric elderly actresses living below them and an odd old man residing above. An unoccupied flat next door, sealed off by a brick wall behind a door in their living room, piques Coraline’s curiosity. Left alone by her preoccupied parents during the summer, she is drawn to this mysterious door. Although her mother has shown her it leads to nothing, Coraline reopens it on her own and discovers a shadowy corridor where bricks once were. This passage leads to a parallel world, a mirror of her own, but one […]

trending_flat
Book Review: Dracula by Bram Stoker

Bram Stoker's "Dracula" is often hailed as a seminal work in both horror and gothic literature. This timeless novel introduces readers to Jonathan Harker, a young solicitor who travels to the remote region of Transylvania to assist Count Dracula with his real estate transactions. Harker's journey quickly takes a dark turn as he realizes that he is a prisoner in Dracula's castle and discovers the Count's true nature as a vampire. The suspense builds as Harker narrowly escapes the castle, only to learn that Dracula has shipped fifty boxes of earth to various locations, securing his ability to rest and regain strength. As Harker returns to England, he joins forces with his fiancée Mina, her friend Lucy, and an array of companions including Dr. John Seward, the brave Quincey Morris, and the knowledgeable Professor Abraham Van Helsing. Together, they confront […]

trending_flat
Top 5 Must-Read Psychological Thrillers

Unraveling the Dark Secrets of the Human Mind Thriller novels have long captivated readers with their blend of suspense, excitement, and mystery. Among the many thriller sub-genres, psychological thrillers carve out a unique niche, focusing on the intricate workings of the human mind rather than relying solely on action or elaborate plots. This genre offers a deep dive into the complexities of characters' mental landscapes, creating a gripping experience that taps into our deepest fears and anxieties. What sets psychological thrillers apart is their ability to generate tension and unease through the labyrinth of the human psyche. Instead of external dangers, these stories often focus on internal conflicts and the psychological manipulations between characters. This can involve unreliable narrators, intricate mind games, and a constant blurring of reality and imagination. The result is a suspenseful, intellectually stimulating read that challenges […]

trending_flat
Top 5 Must-Read Horror Books for This Halloween

Chilling Tales to Keep You Up All Night   Bird Box by Josh Malerman: Josh Malerman plunges us into a profoundly terrifying dystopian world in "Bird Box," where an unseen entity drives those who glimpse it to lethal violence. The story follows Malorie, one of the few survivors five years after the phenomenon began. She embarks on a perilous journey to escape her home, but there's a catch: she must do it blindfolded. This gripping horror novel is a must-read that will keep you on the edge of your seat. The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson: Shirley Jackson, a pivotal figure in horror and science fiction, has inspired countless contemporary authors, including Stephen King and Nigel Kneale. "The Haunting of Hill House" is one of her most renowned works, centered around one of America's most infamous haunted houses. […]

Navigation

Immerse yourself in the world of horror with Superscared. From classic scares to innovative found footage, we deliver the fear you crave. Our curated selection ensures you’ll find the perfect story to haunt your dreams, a premier destination for horror.

Copyright Superscared 2024.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation